MARKET WATCH: US Multifamily Research Tactics


A few weeks ago, we shared CBRE’s third quarter national multifamily report to our investors and followers. The picture was very rosy, overall. With so many reports and market indication studies available, we wanted to compare our own underwriting to more general information available about market data. We researched information for the Albuquerque market and interviewed Josh Rogers, Director of Multifamily to learn more about the academic process the Titan team uses to endorse market health.


We looked specifically at year-over-year rent growth reports from CBRE, Berkadia, Axiometrics, and Yardi to see variations in each report and then applied that information to the underwriting Titan has completed for various Albuquerque-area multifamily projects to see if the information was corroborated.


The bottom line: Titan uses far more specific research tactics than market reporters. Detailed tracking of comparable properties using analytics research technology combined with ‘boots-on-ground’ secret shopping and phone calls for confirmation leads to valid information that is paramount to achieving accurate underwriting.


National Findings Inaccurate and Widely Varied

Our investigation showed major disparities and variations within the national-level reports. National companies have a considerable challenge tracking every property in every market—to say this is a difficult task is an understatement!


Variable rent growth numbers from 0.73% to 3.3% indicate large variations in the respective data sets. After investigating the metrics used, Titan found that the information gathered was inconsistent, often self-reported, and rarely checked for accuracy at the properties themselves. Titan underwriters have consistently found that the best* information, while still imperfect, comes from Axiometrics and uses its data and information to corroborate numbers in person. In general, we are seeing greater growth and returns on par with the macro reports delivered for Q3.


The table shows some of the key metrics we studied:



Accurate Underwriting Through On-The-Ground Data Gathering

Our team will not accept generalities or inaccuracies in place of actual numbers when it comes to data analysis for underwriting. With national numbers differing by a full percentage point and market-specific numbers differing by more than two percent as reflected in the table above, it is critical to confirm assumptions. This is where ‘boots-on-ground’ research comes in. Visiting a multifamily property to see what real concessions are being delivered and what rent is quoted means the in-house data is better than any report. With only approximately five percent of Albuquerque units fitting the Class A description, it is even more important to understand the microcosm in which we invest.


Trending Rents Deteriorates Accuracy

Another key part of Titan underwriting is never trending rents. While the team looks to validate market reports and gather real information for underwriting today, it never assumes growth of any kind—if the deal doesn’t work today, it won’t work tomorrow even with rosy news on the horizon. The team updates underwriting as baselines change resulting in an inflationary mitigant, however it does not trend rents or assume rent growth during the course of the project.


Accurate underwriting is chief to reducing risk and Titan is committed to finding and using conservative, accurate numbers in its analysis of each and every deal.



*Best for the purpose of underwriting specific Titan multifamily projects, i.e. closest comparable metrics.


Titan Fund Management LLC

6300 Riverside Plaza Ln NW, Ste 200

Albuquerque, NM 87120

  • White LinkedIn Icon
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Twitter Icon
  • White Google+ Icon
  • White Instagram Icon

LEGAL DISCLAIMER

Confidentiality Notice
The information contained on this website and any attachment(s) hereto is confidential and may be legally privileged. This website and any attachment(s) is intended only for those recipient(s) directly contacted by Titan Fund Management and affiliates. If you are not one of those intended recipients, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this website, its attachments, or the information herein is strictly prohibited. If you have received attatchments in error, please notify Titan Fund Management and affiliates of that fact and permanently delete the attachments immediately. Please do not retain, copy or use this website or its attachments for any purpose, nor disclose all or any part of its contents to any other person.

Disclosure
1. This is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of any offer to buy any securities. Offers are made only by prospectus or other offering materials. To obtain further information, you must complete our investor questionnaire and meet the suitability standards required by applicable laws.


2. The offer and sale of the membership, partnership and/ or other interests contemplated herein has not been, and will not be, registered under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”), and any interests that are offered and sold will be done so pursuant to exemptions contained in the Securities Act and/or the rules promulgated thereunder.


3. The offer and sale of the membership, partnership and/ or other interests contemplated herein has not been, and will not be, registered or qualified under the laws of any State. Any interests that may be offered and sold will be done so pursuant to the exemptions from registration/qualification contained in the applicable laws of all states applicable to the interests that may be offered.


4. Resale, pledge, hypothecation, or other transfer of any ownership interest in the entity contemplated herein may be limited. The documents included in this booklet are not intended to constitute an offer. In the event that one or more entities is formed to proceed with the fund, formal entity documents will be prepared and available ownership opportunities will be discussed. The recipient of the attached information understands and agrees that, simply because he has been provided this information, he is not guaranteed the opportunity to invest in the contemplated fund and there is no guaranty of any percentage of ownership in the contemplated fund. All parties who obtain an ownership interest, if any, will be reflected in the final, fully executed Partnership Agreement, or other applicable governing documents for the fund entity.


5. The information contained herein is intended to provide general information to allow those that may be interested in the contemplated fund to become reasonably informed on certain matters relating to the contemplated fund. The contemplated fund, identified projects, potential project classifications, and profits therefrom are speculative in nature and thus no warranties, express or implied, are made regarding the profit if any, that an investor may realize. Any projections, budgets, and other financial information is forward looking, speculative and may vary significantly from the actual performance that is realized by the fund or entities in which it is contemplated the fund may invest. Historical data or returns and past performance is not a guaranty of any future performance or returns. Due to the speculative nature of the contemplated fund, an investor could lose part or all of its investment. Parties are encouraged to have this information, any prospectus or similar documents later provided, the limited partnership or other entity documents later provided, and all other documentation relating to the contemplated fund reviewed by such parties’ attorney, tax and investment advisors.


6. The recipient understands that the information provided is intended for the use of the recipient and its advisors only and the recipient agrees not to share the attached information with any other party without the written consent of Titan Fund Management and affiliates. If a party has received this information from any source other than Titan Fund Management and affiliates, such party is advised that the attached information is confidential, is for the use of the intended recipients only, and are requested to immediately return all information to Titan Fund Management and affiliates at the address set forth herein.

© Titan Fund Management